Still, I couldn't help but notice a news clip about the retrials being held to determine if Mary Todd Lincoln was or was not insane. The sold out event was sponsored by the Illinois Supreme Court Historic Preservation Commission and the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum in Springfield. They have put together a prestigious panel of real-life judges, lawyers, doctors and assorted experts to weigh in on both the judicial process and the determination of sanity related to Mary Todd Lincoln's first trial.
Thought Number One: Was Mary Todd Lincoln Crazy?
![]() |
| Can we all agree, how great we all look in our hats??? |
There is a dedicated web site that covered the proceedings aptly named, Was Mary Lincoln Crazy?. I found numerous others, though, that gave more background information. ( why ....yes...I do realize that I am a nerd....thank you for asking!!)
So here in 2012 a group of judges, lawyers, mental health professionals, and audience participants confab to decide if the 1875 jury got it wrong when after a whole ten minutes of deliberation the verdict came back:
"We, the undersigned jurors in the case of Mary Todd Lincoln, having heard the evidence in the case, are satisfied that said Mary Todd Lincoln is insane, and is a fit person to be sent to a state hospital for the insane..." (jury verdict on May 19, 1875).
I gather that the purpose of the retrial was not only to shed light on what changes have evolved in the perception of mental illness, but also, to educate the public as to differences in today's legal process.
Mary Todd Lincoln's case incorporated a number of issues including limited women's rights, biases, and public perceptions. Even after 137 years historians are still divided on if she was insane or if she was railroaded by a kangaroo court.
The events that might of contributed to her behavior and led to her being tried.
As to the actual trial, Mary did not realize that a public trial awaited her, and was forcibly taken to the courthouse on May 19, 1875, by Leonard Swett, a lawyer who knew both Robert and her late husband. Isaac Arnold, a family friend who reluctantly became her defense attorney, did not contest the case, and allowed 17 witnesses to testify to her unstable condition, while not calling any witnesses of his own. During the trial, Robert testified, "I have no doubt my mother is insane. She has long been a source of great anxiety to me." On the same day of her being brought to court, she was tried and sentenced to be committed to a state institution for the insane. She was allowed, however, to be admitted into a private institution in Batavia, Illinois.
Thought Number Two: The Retrials Sided with Mary
Both the retrials found that by today's laws, that she would not have been involuntarily committed. There are no clear answers as to what her real emotional or physical health was. There has long been speculation that she suffered from a bi-polar disorder and clinical depression. Of course, she might of just been eccentric.
No matter, what her issues were, it is clear that she did not get a fair trial.
I gather that the purpose of the retrial was not only to shed light on what changes have evolved in the perception of mental illness, but also, to educate the public as to differences in today's legal process.
Mary Todd Lincoln's case incorporated a number of issues including limited women's rights, biases, and public perceptions. Even after 137 years historians are still divided on if she was insane or if she was railroaded by a kangaroo court.
The events that might of contributed to her behavior and led to her being tried.
- She lost three of her four sons and had bouts of serious depression.
- All through her husband's presidency she had been scrutinized and vilified.
- She was holding her husband hand at the theatre as he was assassinated.
- She had suffered a serious head injury in a carriage accident.
- There were on-going rumors of her husband being unfaithful with Anne Rutledge.
- She had a number of irrational fears including fear of being alone, fire, and poverty.
- She relied extensively on mediums and attended seances regularly to communicate with her deceased family members.
- She wavered between extravagant spending sprees and at other times she hoarded money such as sewing money into the lining of her clothing.
As to the actual trial, Mary did not realize that a public trial awaited her, and was forcibly taken to the courthouse on May 19, 1875, by Leonard Swett, a lawyer who knew both Robert and her late husband. Isaac Arnold, a family friend who reluctantly became her defense attorney, did not contest the case, and allowed 17 witnesses to testify to her unstable condition, while not calling any witnesses of his own. During the trial, Robert testified, "I have no doubt my mother is insane. She has long been a source of great anxiety to me." On the same day of her being brought to court, she was tried and sentenced to be committed to a state institution for the insane. She was allowed, however, to be admitted into a private institution in Batavia, Illinois.
![]() |
| How scandalous in 1875! Today we would call that a consignment store. |
Thought Number Two: The Retrials Sided with Mary
Both the retrials found that by today's laws, that she would not have been involuntarily committed. There are no clear answers as to what her real emotional or physical health was. There has long been speculation that she suffered from a bi-polar disorder and clinical depression. Of course, she might of just been eccentric.
No matter, what her issues were, it is clear that she did not get a fair trial.

Come Join Top Sites Tuesday and be #1 on BlogDumps!
The purpose of this Meme is to encourage
Networking between bloggers and to have fun while doing it!
Make sure to visit all the other participants and leave comments







